Skip to: content | navigation

The ASHA Leader Online

 

Examples of Evidentiary Guidelines for Evaluating Preponderance of Evidence

see also: Feature | OutcomesReferences

Quality  Designation Criteria 
  U. S. Preventive Services Task Force (1989) 
Level I Evidence from one well-conducted randomized clinical trial
Level II-1 Evidence from one well-conducted study with controls but without randomization
Level II-2 Evidence from one well-designed cohort or case-control study preferably from independent researchers
Level II-3 Evidence from multiple time-series single-subject investigations or dramatic results from non-controlled experiments
Level III Opinions of authorities, descriptive studies, case studies, reports of expert committees
  Section 1 Task Force of the Division of Clinical Psychology of the American Psychological Association Task Force (1998)
Demonstrated Effectiveness Two or more well-conducted group-design studies conducted by different research teams showing the treatment to be better than an alternative treatment or equivalent to an already established treatment or a large series of well-conducted single-subject design studies with n > 9 that compare the intervention to another treatment
Probable Efficacy Two or more well-conducted group- and/or single-subject design studies (n < 3) showing the treatment superior to a no-treatment, baseline, or alternative treatment condition or two well-conducted group-design studies meeting criteria for demonstrated effectiveness but both studies conducted by the same research team


©1997-2008 American Speech-Language-Hearing Association - Copyright Notice and Legal Disclaimer